Skip to content


You’re never too old to die for your country

Though, I certainly hope this gentleman doesn’t end up dying for his country — he’s a 70-year old retired doctor who’s been called into service.

Dr. John J. Caulfield was incredulous about the Army’s “unsolicited communication” inviting his return to active duty toward easing increasing wartime demands on military medical treatment facilities.

He disregarded the first postcard last December and the second and subsequent phone messages on the answering machine, not from any unwillingness to serve — “My government has never asked me to do anything I ever refused” — but figuring they used the wrong mailing list, it’s not really me they want. The Army persisted. Would Dr. Caulfield, oral surgeon and Vietnam veteran, retired from military service in 1980 and civilian practice Jan. 1, be willing to return to active duty in, say, Iraq or Afghanistan? The negotiations began with Dr. Caulfield asking, “Do you know how old I am?” They did, and age doesn’t matter, “We want you.” Dr. Caulfield, who turned 70 Aug. 7, reports to Fort Benning, Ga., Oct. 17 for what he and the military describe as “voluntary deployment” with the 325th Combat Support Hospital in Bagram, Afghanistan.

At least it’s good to know that Bush has assured us that our military isn’t overstretched and that there won’t be a draft. After all, why in the world would we need a draft when we can just re-enlist 70-year old retirees? (via Terrance) Update: It’s all a hoax.

So there was Wallace on television Thursday night, telling KNTV (Ch. 11) how excited he was at the prospect of serving his country. A friend of his had called the television station.

The only problem is that the whole thing was a joke — a big one that got out of hand. “It went a little bit farther than I’d planned,” said Wallace’s son-in-law, Mark Flaa of San Jose. “It was supposed to have been a family thing, one of those things you get ribbed about for the next 10 Christmases or something.” Flaa had gone to great lengths to make the joke work — getting copies of a friend’s orders to serve in Iraq and mailing what he wrote to his brother in Seattle, so the letter could be mailed from Fort Lewis in Washington. And he knew his father-in-law would call him, which he did. What he didn’t count on was Wallace going on TV. Flaa didn’t find out until a few minutes before Wallace’s interview with KNTV aired on the 11 o’clock news Thursday night.

<

p>Thanks to Mike for the update!

iTunesYou’ll Be Under My Wheels ” by Prodigy, The from the album Always Outnumbered, Never Outgunned (2004, 3:56).

Posted in Current Affairs. See also: America starts to wake up | That’s up to us as voters | Examining Bush’s military record | The 24.6 Second College Degree | Moving towards reinstating the draft .

4 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. In the case of Dr. Caulfeld it’s a choice and he has chosen to willingly place his life at risk for his country. That’s a perfectly acceptable position and I laud him for “choosing.” I, however, was drafted and went because I felt I owed my country something but stopped way short of my life. In fact, on the forms one signs when one is drafted I pointedly and bluntly said that I would spill any beans I had to preserve my life - I was drafted nonetheless even though the Army knew that I was a potential risk to them. It’s not about the individual, it’s about the numbers of “dead” each side can suffer and still continue to fight. I certainly hope everyone in this country realizes that their individual life doesn’t mean a thing to the military, just their beating heart.

  2. In the case of Dr. Caulfeld it’s a choice and he has chosen to willingly place his life at risk for his country. That’s a perfectly acceptable position and I laud him for “choosing.”

    That’s true, and I should have emphasized that more — once he was sure that the gov’t wasn’t contacting him by accident, he could have said no, yet he chose to accept the assignment. Pretty impressive, actually, and definitely worthy of respect.

    What grabs me more is the simple fact that the military has gotten to the point of calling up people of Dr. Caulfeld’s age. Right now, it’s limited to the medical fields…but how long is that going to last?

  3. As near as I can tell, the first story about Dr. Caulfield is not a hoax. The story you refer to in your update is about another guy, a Mr. Ted Wallace. Two separate people, two separate stories, one a hoax, the other presumably real.

Continuing the Discussion

  1. RelentlesslyOptimistic linked to this post on October 25, 2004

    70 year old doctor recruited by the Army

    eclecticism: You’re never too old to die for your country Trackback

Some HTML is OK

(required)

(required, but never shared)

or, reply to this post via trackback.

Note: This post is over 4 years old. You may want to check later in this blog to see if there is new information relevant to your comment.