Better Buy
Life, Technology January 5th, 2008 |I had to stop by Best Buy today to pick up a new WiFi router for our apartment. Normally, stopping by Best Buy is something I tend to avoid at all costs, and I’ll only go in when I know exactly what I need to get, so I can go in, grab it, and get out as quickly as possible. Today, however, I wasn’t quite sure what router to get (or if it would really be worth getting a new one), so I crossed my fingers and hoped I’d find a sales droid who had at least one and a half, if not two whole brain cells to rub together.
I ended up speaking to two — first, a guy in a green shirt, who was apparently the in-store Clearwire representative, but who happened to be free and knew something about WiFi routers. After describing the situation to him and batting things about, he led me back to the correct shelf, and he snagged a blue shirt on the way. I gave the blue shirt the Readers Digest Condensed Cliffs Notes version of the conversation I’d just had, he recommended a Netgear router to me, and — once again, crossing my fingers — I grabbed it and headed off to work.
(Minor aside: the issue in question was that our D-Link WiFi router seemed to have issues with Hermie, our Vista laptop. The D-Link worked fine over the wired connection with both Macs in the apartment, and connected fine via WiFi to my G5 desktop. Hermie consistently works fine with WiFi in public places — during travels, at the local Panera, and at NSCC — but it had serious issues connecting to the D-Link at home. Some days it would only connect after anywhere from 5 to 30 minutes of repeated tries, other days we wouldn’t be able to get it to connect at all. Needless to say, this has been more than a little frustrating.)
After getting home from work, I unpacked the Netgear router, plugged it in, and went through the installation song and dance, using the ‘Installation Wizard’ on the CD from Hermie. Once it said it was up and running, I checked both desktops via the wired connections, and they were fine. Checked the Airport connection on my G5, it was fine. Rebooted Hermie (to cover all my bases), logged in, and started to head to the ‘Network’ icon down in the try to initialize the connection…but wait, what was that? It was already connected! No muss, no fuss, no error messages telling me it couldn’t connect…it was just there, just like magic. Just like it’s supposed to work.
Thinking back on it, I realized that this now makes five times in a row that I’ve had to go into Best Buy for something, and come out with what I needed, and — when I’ve had to deal with any of the staff — actually not been driven to distraction by their idiocy. In this case, I was actually given good information, and they helped me find what I needed.
I must say, while I’m still no fan of the overall Best Buy experience (their stores tend to come across as oppressive to me…too loud, with aisles that are packed too closely together to make the experience pleasant), five consecutive good experiences have to lead me to admit something of a trend. I don’t know if they’re starting to emphasize more or better training that deals in actual knowledge rather than simple salesmanship, but for some time now, the staff has seemed far more competent than I would have expected.
I may not ever get to a point of just stopping by to browse, or remotely look forward to having to dive into Best Buy…but at least at the moment, I don’t feel the need to actively avoid the store or it’s sales droids when I do stop in. And, for Best Buy, that’s saying a lot.
[See also: Wireless | I need a new router | Random downtime fixed | Everything, everything… | Free Wi-Fi for my apartment? ]
« Condescended | Pre-Seattle Days »
8 Responses to “Better Buy”
Leave a Reply






January 5th, 2008 at 9:02 am
I wish you all the best with the Netgear, but I hated mine … traded it for a Linksys in a New York minute.
January 5th, 2008 at 9:23 am
After one final straw last weekend, we’ve vowed to never shop at Best Buy again, and in fact returned some products we had already purchased from them so as to ensure they don’t get another dime from us ever.
I bought D a gps unit for her car for Christmas (off Amazon) and it was a dud. (Whomever thought it’d be a good idea to put Windows on a navigation device is going to have to answer to me…) Rather than do the whole rigamarole of returning to amazon and getting a new one from amazon, we decided to go to Best Buy where we could have som einstant gratification — and more importantly be able to return it if it sucked. (Which is something that most gps units do in at least one or two ways. The trick is in finding the one unit that sucks in the ways you care about least when you decided to keep it.) Anyway, we picked out a nice juicy ripe one, took it for a spin and found it not only to be not that great, but actually inaccurate in its positioning. So back to the store it went, less than an hour after purchasing.
THe problem is, that they don’t tell you that GPS units are not covered under the store-wide 30 day unconditional return policy, and would not allow a return without a 15% restocking fee. Even when we pointed out that it was not actually working properly (which a sales guy backed us up on, having had a dud version of the same unit himself until swapping it out for a different one.) After much arguing, and hostile language from the returns associate (she actually said “well, he’s full of shit” when we pointed out what the sales guy said.
In any case, I’ve been hearing enough second-hand stories like this (aside from all the well-publicised layoffs and whatnot) that I was thinking of not shopping there anymore, but this just sealed it. I will not be purchasing anything there again.
Sorry to hijack your post
I just figured someone who already feels funny about shopping there might get some benefit from my story.
January 5th, 2008 at 9:27 am
Oh, I lost my train of thought through some of that and left out the ending…
The end of the story is that they would not call a manager (whom I doubt would have helped us anyway) and we ended up just eating the $60 with only our anger and indignation to show for it.
January 5th, 2008 at 6:27 pm
Mike: I’ve had Linksys in the past…had the same experience with mine that you had with your Netgear, apparently. Ended up trading it out for a D-Link. That D-Link (4-port 10/100) worked fine, so I stuck with D-Link when I upgraded to WiFi, and that became the (just resolved) headache. So, having gone through Linksys and D-Link, and refusing to give Belkin money, Netgear was pretty much my choice. So far, so good…
Jer: Heck, hijack away! I pretty much expect that it’s only a matter of time before my Best Buy experience goes back to the ‘norm’ — namely, right along the lines of what you’re describing. However, given that generally speaking, we’re more likely to tell people about bad experiences than good, I figured it was worth noting that I’ve actually lost some of my loathing for Best Buy.
Maybe I should start a betting pool for how long until they piss me off again.
January 5th, 2008 at 11:26 pm
Ironically, Best Buy is one of the brick and mortar stores that I actually prefer, but so far everything that I have purchased from them has worked. I’m not so hot on Verizon, but to each his own.
Michael, I got sucked into a relatively new meme (by Twitter user Doug Haslam a/k/a @DougH), and I’ve therefore invited you to get sucked into it also.
January 7th, 2008 at 12:24 pm
Funnily enough, I’ve had issues with Netgear and Linksys wifi routers, so I stick with D-Link.
But as for Best Buy… here in the Toronto area, they are preferable to the alternative big box electronics store (Future Shop), and actually seem to employ SOME knowledgeable people… but I still prefer going to my smaller local computer stores for computer stuff. They’re way cheaper, and much easier to deal with!
January 8th, 2008 at 9:48 am
Michael, the store I work at carries D-Link and Linksys and you’re welcome to stop by and shop without having to go to Best Buy.
In addition I already know that you know more about computers than I do so I’ll have no need to try and baffle you with bulls**t.
Though I was recently reminded that I must know something because when I needed a wired gigabyte router I went to Best Buy and after the sales staff told me they don’t exist (only wireless versions) Rick and I waited for the staff to leave then I picked it up off the shelf and paid for it.
At least they were nice to me when they told me they didn’t have it.
January 8th, 2008 at 1:11 pm
Ontemp: I’ll see about that meme. Not much for tagging people, but it’s been a while since I’ve been tagged, so I should probably respond.
Ryan: Given that everyone seems to have had issues with one company for another and has another recommendation, I’ve come to the conclusion that it’s all voodoo. High-tech voodoo, but voodoo nonetheless.
Tim: I’ll keep that in mind, but Best Buy has the (possibly unfortunate) convenience of being in easy walking distance from our apartment. Funny (if not entirely surprising) that they didn’t know their own stock, though.